The tricky politics of the burkini backlash
And what it says about the West's excesses of secularism
The images of French police accosting a Muslim woman for dressing too modestly on the beach seem like they're from a different era. These can't be the times we're living in.
But here we are. The laws of some French beach towns frown specifically on a particular form of Islamic modesty, the burkini. French politicians have criticized the burkini in two key ways. The far-right Marine Le Pen finds a way of wrapping the liberated culture of France in conservative language when she says that France should retain the character of the beaches of Bardot. But the more common argument employs left-wing rhetoric. Prime Minister Manuel Valls said, "The burkini is not a new swimsuit fashion trend. It's the translation of a political project for a counter-society based on woman's enslavement."
While French politicians are claiming to use the law to preserve feminist gains from the encroachment of medieval sensibilities, English-language media is aghast at these towns for running afoul of feminism by "telling women what to wear on the beach." French burkini bans are seen as a rearguard action to keep France French. It's racist, they cry.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
But it's also secularism run amok.
For English-speaking countries like the U.S., religion that expresses itself in what a person does and believes as an individual, and how they choose to express their devotion to God in their own behavior, is the most licit form of religion. Secularism for English-speaking countries, meanwhile, tends to be about institutions and how they are ruled. Public institutions are scrubbed of ideas that the public associates with religion. Religious motives are stigmatized in political discourse as illegitimate. And, increasingly, private businesses and even religious institutions, if they serve the public, are asked to disown their religious scruples as they provide medical care, education, or other services. Our secularism is about rules and administration.
But in much of continental Europe secularism is about something else. Germany has also started talking about restrictions on the hijab, precisely because it is a symbol of a "counter-society." For French-speaking communities, secularism is also about the character of society. And so the hijab is banned from schools that are expected to socialize students into this society. The understanding of women's bodies expressed by Manuel Valls is a kind of secular public orthodoxy.
There is, of course, some explosively emotional context in France. Native French are being forced to confront the fact that their society has failed to integrate Muslim immigrants to the French way of living. France has suffered two years of Islamist terror incidents, often perpetrated by people who spent much of their lives in France. To many French, the burkini is seen not as an expression of devotion, but as a gesture of separatism. It indicates a person who looks more toward the Persian Gulf for social cues than to la rive gauche. Almost by instinct, the French reached for terms from feminism to denounce this beachwear. Perhaps in another age, when the fault lines of our politics were on gender and class rather than identity and ethnicity, even American feminists of a more Marxist bent would would have said that a woman who willingly wears this garment is suffering from a false consciousness.
The burkini ban is emotional for Muslims living in France as well. The burkini was designed as swimwear for Muslim women who want to comport themselves with the modesty requirements that go with the hijab even while they swim. The French feminist critique of the hijab and the burkini may have no resonance with many of the French Muslims who choose to wear them. In the Middle East, this clothing may be part of a uniform that is imposed by society, and it may signal a woman's conformation to that society's demands. Psychologically, the social act of wearing the hijab must be different in France. There a hijab can also signify independence and pride. Wearing a hijab in France may say, all at once: I am humble before God, and defiant in the face of social expectations.
Most people in the Anglosphere can glibly pretend that how people dress has no effect on society, when of course it does. In America dress is regulated informally, but effectively, by class and what the Frenchman Alexis de Tocqueville called "common opinion." The French are probably right to sense that something of value in French society is threatened by the religious and social impulses that inspire women to wear the burkini. The appearance of the burkini is in some ways evidence that French society is already divided enough that "common opinion" there lacks the assimilative power it has elsewhere. But everyone else in the world may be right that trying to ban the burkini with the law will only inspire more French Muslims to want to wear it, and divide French society even more.
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Michael Brendan Dougherty is senior correspondent at TheWeek.com. He is the founder and editor of The Slurve, a newsletter about baseball. His work has appeared in The New York Times Magazine, ESPN Magazine, Slate and The American Conservative.
-
'Good riddance to the televised presidential debate'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
Caitlin Clark the No. 1 pick in bullish WNBA Draft
Speed Read As expected, she went to the Indiana Fever
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
Today's political cartoons - April 16, 2024
Cartoons Tuesday's cartoons - sleepyhead, little people, and more
By The Week US Published
-
The Master and Margarita: the new adaptation causing consternation at the Kremlin
Why Everyone's Talking About Pro-Putin groups have called for the film's director to be charged as a terrorist
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
The new 'boom' in Latin American fiction
Why everyone's talking about Almost a quarter of International Booker Prize longlist comes from South America, a region in turmoil
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Poonam Pandey: the Indian model who faked her own death
Why Everyone's Talking About The Bollywood star has a reputation for outlandish stunts
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
Unsung heroes of the year 2023
Under the radar The Week salutes those whose remarkable achievements deserve greater recognition
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
Miss Universe 2023: win for inclusion or nothing to celebrate?
Talking Point Beauty pageant included mothers, plus-sized models and trans women – but fails to distract from global conflict
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Bad Bunny joins in criticism of AI music
Speed Read Concern growing in music industry over generative learning, unauthorised impersonations and copyright issues
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
A reckoning over looted art
The Explainer Thousands of artifacts in U.S. and European collections were stolen from their countries of origin. Should they be sent back?
By The Week Staff Published
-
Fernando Botero obituary: artist of 'whimsical rotundity'
Obituary Colombian painter and sculptor was known for his 'exuberant style'
By The Week Staff Published